The Best Cheese for Pizza: A Guide to Perfect Melting & Flavor

Cheese is one of the most crucial elements of a great pizza. The right cheese brings the perfect balance of creaminess, meltability, stretch, and flavor. Whether you prefer a classic New York slice, a bubbly Neapolitan pizza, or a thick Detroit-style pie, choosing the best cheese can elevate your homemade pizza to pizzeria quality.

In this guide, we’ll break down the best cheeses for pizza, their melting characteristics, and how to pair them for the ultimate pizza experience.

1. Mozzarella – The Classic Choice

Why It’s the Best:

Mozzarella is the gold standard for pizza cheese due to its perfect melt, mild flavor, and signature stretch. It creates the classic gooey, bubbly texture that most people associate with great pizza.

Best Types of Mozzarella for Pizza:

• Low-Moisture Mozzarella: Found in block or pre-shredded form, this cheese has a firmer texture, less water content, and melts evenly without making the pizza soggy.
• Fresh Mozzarella: Comes in a soft, milky form, usually sold in brine or vacuum-sealed. It offers a creamier bite and works best on Neapolitan-style pizza cooked at high temperatures.

Best for: New York-style, Neapolitan, Margherita, and most traditional pizzas.

Pro Tip: If using fresh mozzarella, slice it thinly and pat it dry with a paper towel before adding it to prevent excess moisture on your pizza.

2. Provolone – Smooth & Flavorful

Why It’s Great:

Provolone offers a mild yet slightly tangy flavor, and it melts beautifully. Aged provolone can provide a sharper taste, while young provolone has a smooth, creamy texture.

Best for: Italian-style pizzas, Sicilian pizza, and blending with mozzarella for extra depth of flavor.

Pro Tip: Mix provolone with mozzarella in a 75% mozzarella / 25% provolone ratio for a well-balanced melt and flavor.

3. Cheddar – Bold & Sharp

Why It Works:

Cheddar brings a sharp, rich flavor that adds depth to pizza. While it doesn’t have the best stretch, it blends well with other cheeses for added complexity.

Best for: Detroit-style pizza, barbecue chicken pizza, and loaded-topping pizzas.

Pro Tip: Avoid using only cheddar, as it can become oily when melted. Instead, mix it with mozzarella or provolone for a smoother texture.

4. Parmesan – The Finishing Touch

Why It’s Essential:

Parmesan is not typically used as a base cheese but is a must-have for finishing a pizza. Its bold, nutty, umami-rich flavor enhances every bite.

Best for: Topping off New York-style pizza, Margherita pizza, and white pizza.

Pro Tip: Always grate fresh Parmesan over pizza right after baking for the best taste. Avoid using pre-grated Parmesan, as it often contains anti-caking agents that affect texture.

5. Ricotta – Creamy & Mild

Why It’s Unique:

Ricotta provides a creamy, slightly sweet contrast to melted cheeses. While it doesn’t melt in the same way as mozzarella, it adds richness and a luxurious texture.

Best for: White pizzas, Sicilian-style, and veggie-topped pizzas.

Pro Tip: Dollop small spoonfuls of ricotta onto the pizza before baking for the best creamy texture.

6. Gouda – Smoky & Buttery

Why It’s a Great Addition:

Gouda melts well and has a slightly smoky, buttery flavor. It works exceptionally well on non-traditional pizzas with meats like pulled pork or barbecue chicken.

Best for: Gourmet pizzas, barbecue-style pizzas, and meat-heavy toppings.

Pro Tip: Opt for young Gouda over aged varieties, as it melts better.

7. Fontina – Mild & Creamy

Why It’s Great:

Fontina is an underrated pizza cheese that melts smoothly and adds a creamy, nutty taste to your pizza.

Best for: White pizzas, truffle pizzas, and blended cheese combinations.

Pro Tip: Combine Fontina with mozzarella for a creamier, richer cheese layer.

8. Blue Cheese – Bold & Tangy

Why It’s Unique:

If you love strong flavors, blue cheese brings a sharp, tangy punch to your pizza. It pairs especially well with bold toppings like caramelized onions, pears, or bacon.

Best for: Gourmet pizzas, white pizzas, and experimental flavors.

Pro Tip: Use blue cheese sparingly—it’s strong, and a little goes a long way.

Best Cheese Combinations for Different Pizza Styles

Choosing the right cheese for your pizza can transform your homemade pie into something extraordinary. Whether you’re aiming for a classic stretch, a bold flavor, or a creamy finish, understanding how different cheeses melt and blend will help you create the perfect pizza.

Looking for the best tools to make your pizza even better? Check out our Pizza-Making Equipment Collection to find premium pizza ovens, baking steels, and more.